Your aftershave is as critical as your shaving soap in securing a smooth and cool finish.

We’ve all experienced shaving rash, cuts or razor burn from shaving at one point or another. It’s important to use a good, quality aftershave to sooth and rejuvenate your face, post-shave.

Finding an aftershave that will work best on your skin is like finding a needle in a haystack. There are so many aftershave products on the market today.

To help you narrow down the selection, here’s my review on the best aftershave products that you can buy today.

What is an Aftershave?

As its name implies, an aftershave is a men’s shaving essential that is applied after you scrape off that extra hair on your face.

Aftershave is usually in liquid form (lotion, balm or splash) and is used primarily as an antiseptic and astringent.

Using an aftershave helps you eliminate that itchiness, mild bleeding from cuts, inflammation and feeling of dryness that you usually experience after shaving.

Did You Know…?

Aftershave products can either be scented or unscented. Whether you choose a scented or unscented aftershave, its overall fragrance will change from one person to another, like any other fragrance.

This means that the same aftershave may smell differently on different people.

Types of Aftershave Products

Basically, there are a lot of aftershave products to choose from and each type has its respective advantages and setbacks. Here’s a simple background of each type to help you choose the best aftershave for your skin.

Splash Products for Men

An aftershave splash is more like water considering its physical attributes.

It is an alcohol-based liquid that often delivers a stinging sensation when applied on an open wound.

The main role of an aftershave splash is to close your pores, cleanse your skin, and even out your skin tone.

The main ingredients of an aftershave splash are Aloe Vera and Witch Hazel.

Top Recommendation:

Sale
Sale - Bay Rum Aftershave Splash for Men - Crafted with Authentic Bay Oils from Dominica Republic in The Virgin Islands - Natural and Pure Ingredients - 4oz. - from Barberry Coast Shave Co.
  • YOU DESERVE THE BEST. Handcrafted with all natural, premium ingredients. Each batch of our Bay Rum is filtered and aged to perfection.
  • SAFE, HEALTHY AND GOOD FOR YOUR SKIN. No synthetic chemicals and no artificial colors. Formulated with a unique blend of all natural exotic spices & citrus, essential oils and extracts and the essence of bay leaves from the West Indian Islands. - Vegan, no GMO oils and Parafen Free
  • WILL NOT LEAVE YOUR SKIN DRIED OUT like most alcohol based aftershaves. Carefully formulated with 100% pure glycerin to provide re-moisturizing of your skin.
  • INSTANTLY AWAKENS YOUR SENSES with a crisp, manly burn that quickly diminishes and leaves your skin refreshed, moisturized and toned.
  • 100% LIFETIME GUARANTEE. If you're not completely happy with your purchase we'll refund your money with no questions asked. Proudly Made in the USA.

Source: Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Last update: 2019-05-24

Balm Products for Men

Basically, an aftershave balm is like a splash minus the sting.

It is not alcohol based, which allows it to moisturize and condition the skin without that burning sensation.

Most balms are made of all natural oils, which contribute to the product’s rejuvenating effects.

Top Recommendation:

Calvin Klein OBSESSION for Men After Shave Balm, 5 Fl Oz
  • Launched by the design house of Calvin Klein in 1986
  • It is classified as a flowery fragrance
  • This masculine scent possesses a blend of mandarin and spice, with low tones of musk, sandalwood, and amber
  • Packaging for this product may vary from that shown in the image above

Source: Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Last update: 2019-05-24

Lotion Products for Men

The least popular of the three is the lotion aftershave because of the impression that lotions leave a greasy texture on your skin.

A lotion will contain less alcohol, but just enough to give a mild stinging sensation on the skin.

I’d personally recommend the lotion type for those with dry and flaky skin because of its moisturizing and rejuvenating effects, while still having some antiseptic properties.

Top Recommendation:

Sale
RUGGED & DAPPER Face Moisturizer for Men | 4 Oz. | Daily Anti-Aging Cream + Aftershave Lotion | Unscented | Organic & Natural Ingredients
  • FORMULATED FOR MEN: Combats dryness, signs of aging, breakouts & daily environmental damage.
  • NATURAL & ORGANIC: Nutrient rich ingredients release potent vitamins & minerals to regenerate skin. Includes: Botanical Hyaluronic Acid, Aloe Vera, Jojoba & Shea.
  • HIGHLY EFFECTIVE FORMULA: Fragrance free & quickly absorbs with a masculine shine-free finish.
  • FOR ALL AGES & MOST SKIN TYPES: Normal, sensitive, oily, rough & dry, combo & acne prone complexions.
  • MULTI-PURPOSE BENEFITS: Facial Moisturizer and soothing Aftershave to fuel your face from the inside out.

Source: Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Last update: 2019-05-24

Pro Tip!

Using an aftershave can be quite expensive in the long run, especially if the product you choose requires using more to maximize its promised benefits.

In aftershaves, proper storage is the best way to make sure that the product lasts longer.

And the best place to store your aftershave is in your refrigerator.

Lather and Wood Aftershave Balm

Best After-shave Balm, Sandalwood Scent, Premium Aftershave Lotion, Soothes and Moisturizes Face after shaving, Does Not Dry The Skin, Eliminates Razor Burn For A Silky Smooth Finish …Price: $16.97


Source: Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Last update: 2019-05-24

Lather and Wood Shaving Co. has been in the business of manufacturing high-quality men’s personal care products for many years now.

The aftershave balm by Lather and Wood doesn’t have a single trace of alcohol so it’s perfect for men with sensitive skin.

If you are constantly suffering from irritations and burns every aftershave, this balm could be your perfect solution because it provides a soothing finish without the sting.

It also acts as a moisturizer and doesn’t leave a greasy feeling.

The Pros

  • Doesn’t sting or burn.
  • Great aftershave for sensitive skin.
  • Moisturizer with non-greasy feeling.

The Cons

  • Not good for oily skin.
  • User may need to apply more for effective coverage.
  • Ordinary scent.


Sale
Best After-shave Balm, Sandalwood Scent, Premium Aftershave Lotion, Soothes and Moisturizes Face after shaving, Does Not Dry The Skin, Eliminates Razor Burn For A Silky Smooth Finish …
  • CALMS IRRITATION and eliminates razor burn. Lather & Wood aftershave balm gives unsurpassed cooling and a refreshing finish to your shave. Since its non-drying, it does not sting or burn but calms and soothes irritated skin cause by shaving. This after shave lotion is excellent for sensitive skin.
  • NON-DRYING FORMULA Moisturizes skin, leaving your freshly shaven face with a smooth healthy glow. Do you enjoy using a safety razor or straight razor? This after shave balm is the perfect finish to your classic shaving routine.
  • GOES ON NICE AND SMOOTH. Lather & Woods non-greasy hydrating formula absorbs nicely into the skin, leaving your face feeling silky smooth
  • LIGHT YEARS AHEAD of commercial shaving balms, this after shave balm will be the best after-shave you have ever used. See why our customers never go back to the commercial drugstore brands. A little goes a long way making this a great value with a teriffic old school feel.

Source: Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Last update: 2019-05-24

Rugged and Dapper Aftershave Lotion with Shea

RUGGED & DAPPER Face Moisturizer for Men | 4 Oz. | Daily Anti-Aging Cream + Aftershave Lotion | Unscented | Organic & Natural IngredientsPrice: $24.95


Source: Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Last update: 2019-05-24

A unique entry to this list is the aftershave lotion by Rugged and Dapper, which also works as an anti-aging cream.

Whether or not you have been shaving, you can use it daily to help reduce those age marks on your face.

As an aftershave lotion, it helps soothe any irritation caused by shaving through its shea butter content. This is also good for all skin types.

The Pros

  • Double purpose – aftershave lotion and anti-aging cream in one product.
  • Absorbs quickly on the skin for faster results.
  • Push spray bottle for ease of use.

The Cons

  • Pump may easily break
  • Leaves a greasy feeling on your face.
  • Red flag for those allergic to niacin. Niacinamide ingredient can trigger allergic reactions.


Sale
RUGGED & DAPPER Face Moisturizer for Men | 4 Oz. | Daily Anti-Aging Cream + Aftershave Lotion | Unscented | Organic & Natural Ingredients
  • FORMULATED FOR MEN: Combats dryness, signs of aging, breakouts & daily environmental damage.
  • NATURAL & ORGANIC: Nutrient rich ingredients release potent vitamins & minerals to regenerate skin. Includes: Botanical Hyaluronic Acid, Aloe Vera, Jojoba & Shea.
  • HIGHLY EFFECTIVE FORMULA: Fragrance free & quickly absorbs with a masculine shine-free finish.
  • FOR ALL AGES & MOST SKIN TYPES: Normal, sensitive, oily, rough & dry, combo & acne prone complexions.
  • MULTI-PURPOSE BENEFITS: Facial Moisturizer and soothing Aftershave to fuel your face from the inside out.

Source: Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Last update: 2019-05-24

Proraso Aftershave Splash

Proraso After Shave Lotion, Refreshing and Toning, 3.4 Fl OzPrice: $14.00


Source: Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Last update: 2019-05-24

Proraso has been in the business of producing top quality men’s grooming products for more than a century.

With long and prove track record, Proraso’s Aftershave splash naturally makes this list.

You can enjoy a cool and refreshed feeling after every use with light and appealing scent.

If you suffer from inflammation after shaving, you can use this aftershave splash because it will soothe burns thanks to its Witch Hazel ingredient.

The Pros

  • Fast refreshing relief mechanism.
  • Made with menthol and eucalyptus oil for skin revitalization.
  • Nice sent which can be similar to that of a cologne.

The Cons

  • Burning sensation when applied.
  • Not good for men with overly sensitive skin.
  • Scent quickly dissipates.


Proraso After Shave Lotion, Refreshing and Toning, 3.4 Fl Oz
  • Anti-irritation, for sensitive skin
  • Menthol refreshes and revitalizes
  • No parabens; No silicons; No mineral oils; No artificial colors

Source: Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Last update: 2019-05-24

Clubman Pinaud Aftershave Lotion

Clubman after shave lotion 6 fl ozPrice: $4.80


Source: Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Last update: 2019-05-24

This lotion acts as a skin toner and an effective preemptive solution to razor rash.

The product is alcohol based so you can expect a burning sensation when applied on your face.

The scent is a classic barbershop essence.

Clubman Pinaud is also good at helping you get through those dolorous razor nicks.

The Pros

  • Strong, masculine scent.
  • Cool and refreshed feeling after application.
  • Manufacturer has been in the industry for more than 200 years.

The Cons

  • Stings and burns are to be expected since it is alcohol based.
  • Some people may find the scent rather unattractive.
  • Scent can be overwhelming to others and can trigger headaches.


Sale
Clubman after shave lotion 6 fl oz
  • Cools, exhilerates
  • Soothers tender skin
  • Helps heal razor nicks
  • Suave, masculine fragrance

Source: Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Last update: 2019-05-24

Nivea for Men Sensitive Post Shave Balm

NIVEA Men Sensitive Post Shave Balm - Soothes and Moisturizes Skin After Shaving - 3.3 fl. oz. Bottle (Pack of 3)Price: $14.94


Source: Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Last update: 2019-05-24

Nivea is a very popular brand for personal care products for both men and women.

Its product lines range from deodorants and sunscreens to face and body creams and lotions.

Nivea for Men Sensitive Post Shave Balm is a good aftershave alternative for men with sensitive skin.

It’s an effective solution for all those skin redness and irritations.

The product is also specially formulated to lessen skin’s sensitivity through time if you use it regularly.

The Pros

  • Safe to use on sensitive skin.
  • Faster results as the liquid is quickly absorbed by the skin.
  • Witch Hazel and Chamomile combination for soothing effects.

The Cons

  • Scent is barely noticeable.
  • Mildly formulated. Not an ideal choice to those looking for a strong and refreshing aftershave.
  • Light scent but similar to that of a women’s lotion.


NIVEA Men Sensitive Post Shave Balm - Soothes and Moisturizes Skin After Shaving - 3.3 fl. oz. Bottle (Pack of 3)
  • Helps protect skin from shaving irritations
  • Improve skin's condition over time
  • Formulated with no drying alcohol
  • Lightly fragranced
  • Skin compatibility dermatologically tested by men with sensitive skin

Source: Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Last update: 2019-05-24

Considering Your Skin Type

When finding for the right aftershave, it’s essential to consider your skin type and sensitivity.

Men have various types of skin that require different levels of treatment after every shave.

Men’s Aftershave For Dry Skin

A common skin condition among people living in a cold climate is skin dryness.

So if you happen to live in a country that enjoys cold winter months or sweltering hot and arid summers, it is best to go for an aftershave balm.

It helps your skin lock in more moisture and even rejuvenates it without the sting.

Top Recommendation:

MARLOWE. No. 123 Men's Facial Moisturizer 6 oz | Lightweight Daily Face Lotion for Men | Best for Dry or Oily Skin | Made with Natural Ingredients & Anti-Aging Extracts
  • HYDRATE DRY SKIN, NO GREASY FEELING: This lightweight face moisturizer for men brings hydration and to a cleansed face, providing natural anti-aging moisturizing effects. This cream works great on oily skin.
  • EXPERIENCE THE MARLOWE DIFFERENCE: Our men's face lotion is made with our proprietary Marlowe. M Blend: a unique natural formulation of passionflower fruit, green tea, and willow bark extracts designed to best nourish, smooth, and revitalize skin.
  • REFRESHING SCENT: Lightly scented with a clean balance of aloe and citrus followed by a woody base.
  • WATER-BASED NATURAL LOTION: Our Face cream is suitable for all skin types, but especially for those with oily skin, being a water-based lotion and extremely lightweight (while packing a great punch of nourishing extracts).
  • NO BAD STUFF & MADE RIGHT HERE: Paraben-free and phthalate-free, cruelty-free (not tested on animals), and made in the USA.

Source: Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Last update: 2019-05-24

Men’s Aftershave For Oily Skin

Lotion is a nightmare among men with oily skin simply because that extra greasiness is definitely the last thing they need.

I’d personally recommend an aftershave splash because it helps in keeping your skin feeling cool and refreshed while effectively taming your overactive sebum glands that produce excess oil on your face.

Top Recommendation:

Sale
RUGGED & DAPPER Face Wash for Men | 8 Oz. | Daily Scrub + Facial Cleanser + Toner In One | Combats Aging & Breakouts | Organic & Natural Ingredients
  • FORMULATED FOR MEN: Deep cleans, attacks dirt, excess oil & grime to eliminate breakouts & acne, without stripping skin of moisture.
  • MULTI-PURPOSE BENEFITS: Energizing Face Wash, Toner and Exfoliator that covers all the bases, for a clean and revitalized complexion.
  • HIGHLY EFFECTIVE FORMULA: Prevents congestion and the advancement of aging. Plant based exfoliants remove dead skin cells, smooth and prepare the skin for a clean shave.
  • NATURAL & ORGANIC: Nutrient rich ingredients borrowed from the outdoors release potent vitamins & minerals to regenerate skin. Includes: Aloe Vera, Vitamin C, Willow Bark and Burdock Root.
  • FOR ALL AGES & SKIN TYPES: Normal, sensitive, oily, rough & dry, combo & acne prone complexions.

Source: Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Last update: 2019-05-24

Men’s Aftershave For Oily Skin

Lotion is a nightmare among men with oily skin simply because that extra greasiness is definitely the last thing they need.

I’d personally recommend an aftershave splash because it helps in keeping your skin feeling cool and refreshed while effectively taming your overactive sebum glands that produce excess oil on your face.

Top Recommendation:

Sale
RUGGED & DAPPER Face Wash for Men | 8 Oz. | Daily Scrub + Facial Cleanser + Toner In One | Combats Aging & Breakouts | Organic & Natural Ingredients
  • FORMULATED FOR MEN: Deep cleans, attacks dirt, excess oil & grime to eliminate breakouts & acne, without stripping skin of moisture.
  • MULTI-PURPOSE BENEFITS: Energizing Face Wash, Toner and Exfoliator that covers all the bases, for a clean and revitalized complexion.
  • HIGHLY EFFECTIVE FORMULA: Prevents congestion and the advancement of aging. Plant based exfoliants remove dead skin cells, smooth and prepare the skin for a clean shave.
  • NATURAL & ORGANIC: Nutrient rich ingredients borrowed from the outdoors release potent vitamins & minerals to regenerate skin. Includes: Aloe Vera, Vitamin C, Willow Bark and Burdock Root.
  • FOR ALL AGES & SKIN TYPES: Normal, sensitive, oily, rough & dry, combo & acne prone complexions.

Source: Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Last update: 2019-05-24

Men’s Aftershave For Sensitive Skin

There will always be people whose skin will easily react on some active ingredients of a particular personal care product.

In the case of aftershave, I’d recommend choosing for one that is unscented and alcohol-free.

Top Recommendation:

Sale
Gillette After Shave Gel, Sensitive Skin, 2.5 Ounce (Pack of 6)
  • Made especially for sensitive skin, this lightly scented gel instantly cools and refreshes just shaved skin
  • Non-greasy formulation made specifically for sensitive skin
  • Rub it in after your shave or anytime you need a shot of long-lasting cool

Source: Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Last update: 2019-05-24

Men’s Aftershave For Normal Skin

You probably wouldn’t have any problem whatsoever trying out different types of aftershave products.

You will only have to consider your lifestyle and some personal preferences on this one.

Top Recommendation:

Paula's Choice PC4MEN Soothe + Smooth Aftershave Treatment & Exfoliant for Men | Salicylic Acid | Non-Drying & Fragrance Free | 3 Ounce
  • SOOTHE AND SMOOTH: Address bumps, help stop skin from looking older, calm redness, and soften skin all in one non-irritating, fragrance-free formula. Delivers dramatic results with its combination of potent exfoliating and anti-aging ingredients.
  • Paula's Choice PC4MEN Soothe + Smooth Aftershave Treatment and Exfoliant for Men with Salicylic Acid calms redness doesn't sting softens skin vanquishes redness and minimizes signs of aging. Our aftershave leaves skin smooth soft and touchable.
  • Use this hydrating, soothing aftershave as part of your shaving routine, in tandem with your PC4MEN cleanser. For daytime use, follow with an SPF 30+ moisturizer.
  • Paula's Choice products are made with YOUR SKIN in mind. Whatever your skincare concern, whether dryness, acne, fine lines, or sensitive skin; we've got a treatment line for you. The search for amazing skin care ends here. Finally, you found it.
  • Look to Paula's Choice for highly effective skin care solutions for face & body. Our line of facial cleansers, exfoliators, toners, moisturizers, serums, eye creams, facial masks, sunscreens, body washes & more are made to care for every kind of skin.

Source: Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Last update: 2019-05-23

Watch this video on how to properly apply aftershave:

Important Ingredients In An Aftershave Products

As discussed earlier, the main role of an aftershave is to cleanse, moisturize, condition, rejuvenate, and even out the tone of the skin after scraping that unwanted beard off of your face.

This is made possible by the main ingredients of the product – witch hazel, alcohol, aloe vera, and tea tree oil.

Alcohol

Alcohol’s main role is to disinfect the skin while leaving behind a cool and refreshed feeling. An aftershave splash contains high alcohol concentration, which explains the stinging result after every application.

Alcohol, however, is not suitable for men with sensitive and dry skin and can only aggravate irritations and wounds.

Witch Hazel

Witch Hazel is a natural astringent which helps in closing the skin’s pores. Unlike alcohol, Witch Hazel doesn’t dry out the skin and has anti-inflammatory properties.

It also performs as a gentle cleansing agent.

Aloe vera

The soothing effects of an aftershave is mainly because of its Aloe vera ingredient.

Aloe vera acts as a natural healing agent which is essential in helping your skin heal from those aftershave cuts and burns.

Tea Tree Oil

Tea tree oil is often paired with Witch Hazel to deliver the best soothing effects of an aftershave.

Tea Tree Oil works mainly as an antiseptic that helps the skin avoid infections.

Aloe Vera

Aloe Vera is a plant with anti-inflammatory and antiseptic qualities, making it a great ingredient in men’s aftershave.

Aftershave Fragrance

Fragrance is basically the least important factor to consider and is more of a personal preference.

Besides, you wouldn’t want to keep on using an aftershave that has a scent that you really dislike.

Much like choosing a cologne or perfume, aftershaves have strings of scents to choose from.

You should also consider your skin type because it can directly affect the duration of the aftershave’s fragrance.

Scents wear out faster on dry skin faster and linger longer on oily skin.

The Verdict

Of the five aftershaves I reviewed, I highly recommend the Rugged and Dapper Aftershave Lotion with Shea.

RUGGED & DAPPER Face Moisturizer for Men | 4 Oz. | Daily Anti-Aging Cream + Aftershave Lotion | Unscented | Organic & Natural IngredientsPrice: $24.95


Source: Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. Last update: 2019-05-24

It’s a versatile aftershave because all skin types can use it and it comes with shea butter that helps deliver a soothing relief from skin irritations.

It is also a double purpose product which acts as an aftershave and an anti-aging cream at the same time.